Do You Take Cigars Out of Plastic to Put in Humidor, or Do You Let the Moon Decide?

Cigars, humidors, and the mysteries of the universe—these are the topics that ignite passionate debates among aficionados and casual enthusiasts alike. The question of whether to remove cigars from their plastic wrappers before placing them in a humidor is one that has sparked countless discussions, theories, and even a few heated arguments. But what if the answer lies not in the realm of logic, but in the whims of celestial bodies? Let us dive into this smoky, enigmatic topic with a blend of practicality, philosophy, and a dash of absurdity.

The Practical Perspective: To Unwrap or Not to Unwrap?

At its core, the question of removing cigars from their plastic wrappers is a practical one. Cigars are delicate creations, requiring specific conditions to maintain their flavor, aroma, and structural integrity. A humidor, designed to regulate humidity and temperature, is the ideal environment for storing cigars. But does the plastic wrapper hinder or help this process?

Arguments for Removing the Plastic:

1. Better Humidity Control: Plastic wrappers can act as a barrier, preventing the cigar from fully absorbing the humidity in the humidor. Removing the wrapper allows the cigar to “breathe” and interact directly with the controlled environment.
2. Enhanced Aging: Many cigar enthusiasts believe that unwrapped cigars age more gracefully, allowing the flavors to meld and develop over time.
3. Aesthetic Appeal: There’s something undeniably satisfying about seeing a collection of unwrapped cigars neatly arranged in a humidor. It’s a visual treat that adds to the overall experience.

Arguments for Keeping the Plastic On:

1. Protection from Damage: The plastic wrapper acts as a shield, protecting the cigar from physical damage, such as cracks or tears, especially in a crowded humidor.
2. Preservation of Flavor: Some argue that the plastic wrapper helps retain the cigar’s original flavor by preventing it from absorbing odors from other cigars or the humidor itself.
3. Convenience: Leaving the wrapper on means less hassle when selecting a cigar to smoke. It’s ready to go, no unwrapping required.

The Philosophical Angle: What Does the Cigar Want?

If we venture beyond practicality, we enter the realm of philosophy. What does the cigar itself desire? Does it yearn to be free from its plastic confines, or does it find comfort in its protective cocoon? This line of thinking might seem whimsical, but it raises an interesting point: our relationship with cigars is deeply personal and often emotional.

The Cigar as a Living Entity:

Some aficionados treat their cigars as if they were living beings, carefully nurturing them in the humidor. From this perspective, removing the plastic wrapper is akin to setting the cigar free, allowing it to “live” and “breathe” in its natural habitat.

The Cigar as a Work of Art:

Others view cigars as masterpieces, each one a unique creation deserving of preservation. In this case, the plastic wrapper is seen as a frame, protecting the artwork from the ravages of time and environment.

The Absurdist Approach: Let the Moon Decide

Now, let us take a leap into the absurd. What if the decision to remove the plastic wrapper is not ours to make? What if it is dictated by the phases of the moon, the alignment of the stars, or the whims of cosmic forces?

Lunar Influence on Cigars:

Could it be that cigars stored during a full moon benefit from the plastic wrapper, while those stored during a new moon thrive without it? Perhaps the moon’s gravitational pull affects the cigar’s moisture levels in ways we have yet to understand.

Astrological Considerations:

Maybe your zodiac sign plays a role in this decision. Are Leos more likely to unwrap their cigars, while Virgos prefer to keep them protected? The possibilities are endless—and delightfully nonsensical.

The Cultural Perspective: Traditions and Superstitions

Cigars have a rich cultural history, and with that comes a variety of traditions and superstitions. In some cultures, removing the plastic wrapper is seen as a sign of respect for the cigar and its maker. In others, the wrapper is considered an essential part of the cigar’s identity.

Cuban Traditions:

In Cuba, the birthplace of many legendary cigars, there are stories of cigar makers who insist that the plastic wrapper must remain on until the moment of smoking. This is said to preserve the cigar’s “soul.”

Modern Superstitions:

Some modern enthusiasts swear by specific rituals, such as whispering a secret to the cigar before removing the wrapper or storing it in a humidor lined with cedar from a particular forest.

The Scientific Approach: What Does the Research Say?

While much of the discussion around cigars and humidors is based on anecdotal evidence, there is some scientific research that sheds light on the matter.

Humidity and Plastic:

Studies have shown that certain types of plastic can indeed impede the transfer of moisture. However, the extent to which this affects the cigar’s quality is still up for debate.

Aging and Flavor Development:

Research into the aging process of cigars suggests that exposure to air can accelerate chemical reactions that enhance flavor. This supports the argument for removing the plastic wrapper.

The Personal Choice: Trust Your Instincts

Ultimately, the decision to remove the plastic wrapper or leave it on comes down to personal preference. Some smokers swear by one method, while others find success with the opposite. The key is to experiment and find what works best for you and your cigars.

Tips for Experimentation:

1. Try Both Methods: Store some cigars with the wrapper on and others without. Compare their condition and flavor over time.
2. Keep a Journal: Document your observations to track which method yields the best results.
3. Seek Advice: Talk to fellow enthusiasts and learn from their experiences.

Related Q&A

Q: Can I reuse the plastic wrapper after removing it? A: While it’s technically possible, reusing the wrapper is not recommended. It may have absorbed odors or moisture that could affect the cigar’s flavor.

Q: Does the type of humidor affect whether I should remove the plastic? A: Yes, the type of humidor can play a role. For example, a well-sealed humidor with precise humidity control might make the plastic wrapper less necessary.

Q: How long can I store cigars in a humidor? A: With proper care, cigars can be stored in a humidor for years, even decades. The key is to maintain consistent humidity and temperature levels.

Q: Do flavored cigars require different storage considerations? A: Yes, flavored cigars should ideally be stored separately to prevent their aromas from affecting other cigars in the humidor.

Q: Is it true that cigars can “talk” to each other in a humidor? A: While cigars don’t literally communicate, they can influence each other’s flavors and aromas, especially if stored together for long periods. This is why some enthusiasts prefer to keep different types of cigars in separate humidors.